As a long-time reader of
Salon, I was disappointed when they added an open comments section to all of their articles. An article a couple of months ago explained the rationale behind that, and detailed their experience with the whole thing. I'd occasionally read the letters to the editor that they published, but rarely do I read the comments about an article. If I do take a look, I choose the "starred letters" option, because I have no desire to see two hundred comments that devolve after about the third one into incoherent, spittle-laced cheap shots and mostly incorrect grammatical nitpicking. There's a serious level-of-discourse problem there. If I wanted to read the insane ravings of random anonymous nutjobs, there are millions of blogs to choose from. I choose to read the blogs of the people I find interesting and well-spoken and funny and thoughtful.
Reading a thoughtful, well-researched article, then opening up the comments to see hateful, vitriolic, and bileful screaming matches is really jarring and unpleasant. It's like there's a continuous barroom brawl going on just under the surface. An article today mentions that they're going to be rolling out some kind of comment control system, which is great, but I'm already a little turned off to the whole thing.
Salon actually published a couple of my letters to the editor, which I was really proud of at the time. Getting a star next to my comment is nice, but it's not really the same experience when it's sandwiched between two people who are bickering about the past subjunctive.
I only make comments - on Salon and on the blogs I read - when I really feel like I'm saying something that adds to the ongoing discussion or debate. I like sending e-mails much better. Except on the blogs of friends, where I know many of the other commenters, directing public conversation to a writer just feels strange.
I stumbled across a knitblog (and am loathe to try to find it again) where a woman mentioned offhand that she can't understand why someone would have a blog without comments, and it started a firestorm of debate (and insults aimed at her) in the comments. Is that enough right there?
The argument that the good, positive feedback outweighs the bad, rabid feedback makes sense to me. I can see why people have that attitude. I can see why people have comments and enjoy comments and read and write comments. I would be seriously uncomfortable, though, with getting a bunch of comments on every post about how nice my knitwork is or how funny or interesting my writing is. I mean, I'm secure enough in these things to post a bunch of it on the internets, so it's not exactly that I automatically think anyone saying anything nice is a filthy liar. It's just that I enjoy much more pretending that the internets and my place in it exist in my closet, where only I can see it. And I feel like I would implicitly be asking the fewer-than-10 friends who know this blog exists to give me positive reinforcement every time I post.
I think Mick Jagger was the one who said it's easier to sing in front of millions of people than 10 people because when it's a million, you can't see any of them. I can really relate to that.
It's a little embarrassing, actually, how much of my social life happens with people whom I've never seen in person and many of whom don't know I exist, but I've really made peace with it. When I was a kid, I'd hang out with a few people, spend a lot of time alone (if I don't get alone time, watch the hell out), and read books by authors who were long dead. Now I hang out with a few people, correspond with others, spend a lot of time alone, and read the blogs of people who are having similar experiences as I am and writing wonderfully about them. If I'm feeling socially brave, I'll write them an e-mail to say how much I like their work and point them back to my writing, but it's okay even if I'm not feeling that way. I just read their blogs every day. (You can get the communication of ideas, feelings of solidarity (solidarity? communiality? ??), and amusement
without having to talk to anyone in person. Brilliant.)
Very very occasionally I'll get an e-mail like that, from a friend or a stranger, and it's a great feeling to know that people are enjoying and valuing my work as much as I am theirs. If I weren't such an uptight overly-careful introvert weirdo, I might be able to get that feeling the way most people can, through the comments.
But alas. I cannot.
Tomorrow: tune in to see if sleeping in a nice but too-stiff button down shirt leaves it fashionably sueded and rumpled!